Choosing a Reef in Asia: Raja Ampat, Komodo and the Maldives
The richest reefs of the Coral Triangle and the atolls of the Indian Ocean offer three different trips: a remote dive resort, a boat among dragons and currents, or an island resort with mantas offshore. How to choose, and the hotels doing something for the reef.
For anyone who travels to be in the water, Asia has two great reef systems. In the east, the Coral Triangle, between Indonesia, the Philippines and New Guinea, holds the greatest diversity of reef life on earth. In the west, the Maldives is a chain of coral atolls rising from the Indian Ocean. They are often compared, but they offer different trips, and the choice depends less on the fish than on how one wants to live while seeing them.
Raja Ampat: the remote dive resort
Off the western tip of New Guinea, Raja Ampat lies at the heart of the Coral Triangle; the wider Bird’s Head Seascape counts some 600 species of hard coral. It is far away, reached by a flight to Sorong and then by boat, and the accommodation is built for divers rather than for luxury in the usual sense. Misool was founded on the site of a shark-finning camp and uses its twenty rooms to pay for a marine reserve of more than 1,200 square kilometres; Sorido Bay, at Cape Kri, was built by the pioneer of diving in the islands; Papua Paradise stands on stilts over its house reef. OKYTO’s article on choosing between schooner, expedition ship and dive resort sets out the options, including a private phinisi and the Aqua Blu expedition yacht.
Komodo: dragons and currents
West of Raja Ampat, within the same Coral Triangle, Komodo combines two attractions in one national park: the dragons on land and some of the strongest currents and richest dive sites in Indonesia offshore, with manta rays at cleaning stations. Most visitors explore from a boat, by day trip or liveaboard, from the harbour town of Labuan Bajo on Flores. OKYTO’s Komodo guide covers the dragons, the reefs and the boats, and a ranger-led walk is the essential land excursion. TA’AKTANA, a Luxury Collection resort, has given Labuan Bajo its first hotel of that standard.
The Maldives: the island resort
The Maldives works the other way round: one resort to an island, and the reef as part of the hotel. The comfort is unmatched, and the marine life comes to the guest. The great spectacle is in Baa Atoll, a UNESCO biosphere reserve, where plankton draws manta rays and whale sharks into Hanifaru Bay during the south-west monsoon; OKYTO describes how to snorkel with them under the rules of the protected area. The Maldives guide compares atolls before resorts. Among the newer resorts, Soneva Secret, in a little-dived lagoon in the far west, runs a coral nursery, and Joali Being in Raa Atoll puts wellbeing before diving.
Reefs nearer the cities
Not every reef needs a long expedition. In Sabah, Gaya Island Resort, a short boat ride from Kota Kinabalu, runs a turtle rescue centre and grows coral fragments with Reef Check Malaysia. On the coast of central Vietnam, Zannier Bãi San Hô is named after the bay of corals it encloses. And in Japan, Rosewood Miyakojima chose a subtropical island of coral reefs for the brand’s Japanese debut.
How to choose
Divers with experience and time should go east: Raja Ampat for diversity and remoteness, Komodo for currents and big animals. Snorkellers, families and those who want the reef as one part of a stay will find the Maldives easier. In all three, the season matters more than the hotel: sea conditions and visibility vary through the year and between sites, and the best boats and rooms sell out first for the calmest months.
Mentioned